Convergence Review (MILD SPOILERS)

-

Phase II of the High Republic is here and with it comes hype, expectations, a new time period and new authors. I do have worries about this new phase, not the new authors but leaving behind the characters and time period we are used to, and the fact it feels like it’s been a while since Phase I finished, would I still be into the project as much?

My other worry was because of the delayed UK release of Path of Deceit and Convergence being my first review copy from Del Rey, I received both books on the same day so I decided to read Convergence first in order to get this review out promptly. How would that effect my reading experience?


Phase II is set 150 years BEFORE the events of Phase I, and the story is set on the twin planets, E’ronoh and Eiram who have been at war for decades and focuses on a ceasefire hanging by a thread on the the proposed marriage of Xiri and Phan-tu the children of the respective ruling families. The Jedi, Republic officials, Xiri and Phan-tu must win over the people whilst contending with forces wishing to destroy the fragile peace before they can be married.


I really enjoyed this time period and how it is differentiated from Phase I, the Republic is still expanding and travel and communication between the core and the Outer Rim is difficult, which means there are two Chancellors, Kyong Greylark on Coruscant and Orlen Mollo who travels the Outer Rim. I am also enjoying the importance given to Jedha in this era, it is referred to a number of times as the spiritual centre of the galaxy with multiple faiths revering it, this is shown in the High Republic comic and will feature in George Mann’s forthcoming audio drama The Battle of Jedha.

My favorite character is undoubtedly Gella Nattai a young Jedi Knight trying to find her purpose in the Order and the galaxy, she is assigned to protect the young couple as they tour their planets to spread word of the ceasefire. The characters of Princess Xiri A’lbaran, a captain in E’ronoh’s navy and adoptive Prince Phan-tu Zenn and their growing relationship are fantastic and Zoraida Cordova does an excellent job of illustrating that. As they go from entering the betrothal out of a sense of duty and desire to end the war to trusting and respecting one another and finally developing genuine feelings. This strength should come as no surprise as Cordova comes from a romance background, and to be honest I would have liked even more of this aspect of the story.

For me the best part of the book was the peace summit on board Chancellor Mollo’s ship, The Paxion, there is great tension bringing together the families and advisors for the warring planets in one confined space. 


But we need to talk about Axel Greylark, amongst the review community I have seen a lot of love for his character and I’m sad to say I just can’t see it. Axel is the son of the Chancellor Greylark and an entitled party boy who doesn’t seem to care for anyone, hates the Jedi as he blames them for his father’s death and is sent by his mother to be her representative at the summit despite his many scandals. Through the book he is humanized, and actually begins to care for Gella, only for his actions late in the book, that I don’t wish to spoil, make me wonder how anyone could like him and just what his arc is as he doesn’t really seem to change in a meaningful way.


Zoraida Cordova has written in the Star Wars universe before, a YA novel Crash of Fate, and to me this book feels more like a YA novel than an adult story. I have no problems with Young Adult novels, they are some of my favorite Star Wars books but when it is meant to be an adult novel it is a bit of an issue. I had problems with the pacing of some of the book, and didn’t really feel gripped until the peace summit or indeed for large parts after it.


I did also  feel like I was missing something having not read Path of Deceit yet, especially more information about the Path of the Open Hand, they were mostly in the background of this story and their motivations were unclear, and made me feel like I could not see the importance of these events in the overall story of the High Republic. I will be interested to see if my feelings for this book change once I have read Path of Deceit.


To end on a positive, I really enjoyed the ending of the book, there is hope for the future of the twin planets with Xiri and Phan-tu, a miserable end for Axel, and Gella declaring that she wishes to become a Wayseeker, I really hope we see more of her in the rest of this phase.


🌕🌕🌕🌘🌑/5


Jonny O

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Book Of Boba Fett Trailer Review

-
Image
Hello there! After a month off from the blog, the release of the first The Book Of Boba Fett trailer has brought me back. When this series was announced at the end of The Mandalorian Season 2, I wasn’t particularly hyped for it, and felt it overshadowed the Mandalorian somewhat, and that despite the fact I’ve always been a fan of Boba, I own Fett artwork, figures and clothing! The trailer looks very cool, very Tatooine and  Jabba’s  Boba’s Palace centric, and jam packed with Original Trilogy and Return of the Jedi aliens, from Gamorrean Guards, to Twi’leks, Tuskens, Trandoshans and my favorite species of all - an Ithorian with a speaking role!!! Which makes this nerd wonder if his boy Max Rebo could make an appearance, every crimelord needs entertaining right?! There are some great visuals, the Tusken’s walking through the sandstorm, the huge sunken city both stuck in my mind. The story seems to be focused on Boba Fett taking over Jabba’s criminal underworld which has fractur...
Read more

Into The Dark Book Review [SPOILERS]

-
Image
  This was the second High Republic novel for me, and Claudia Gray is my favorite Star Wars author so there was a bit of pressure for me. Into the Dark is a Young Adult novel, but we know from Lost Stars that is no problem. I loved this entry into the High Republic story but I don’t think it quite cracks my Claudia Gray top 3. Claudia Gray’s biggest strength is getting inside characters heads, and each of her previous books has really focused on one or two characters, but Into the Dark is far more of an ensemble, and I did miss that laser focus a little. However I really liked all of the characters in this book and they all get plenty of development, Reath, our main protagonist I really connected with. He is a bookish and studious padawan, who prefers to read about adventure rather than experience it and I found it interesting that he was described as not having as strong a connection to the force but making up for it with hard work and knowledge. I don’t want to ignore the rather ...
Read more

Shadow of the Sith Review [SPOILERS]

-
Image
Shadow of the Sith is one of the most anticipated Star Wars books of recent years, with a lot of pressure put upon it by many to explain events in the sequel trilogy. So did it live up to expectations? For me it does, not that I expected it to explain everything - we have plenty of time to explore and fill in the intervening years between Return of the Jedi and The Force Awakens. Let’s not forget that it took    9 years for us to learn why the Clones turned on the Jedi so easily (season 6 of the Clone Wars in 2014). There are two main threads to the story, Lando trying to save Rey’s family from Ochi of Bestoon and Luke’s discovery of a mysterious dark side user. The book is littered with connections to all parts of Star Wars canon, the Acolytes of Beyond first mentioned in the Aftermath trilogy play an important part, Luke goes to Tython which we saw in the Mandalorian, a young Enric Pryde (TROS) makes an appearance as does Shriv Suurgav who first appeared in Battlefront II. T...
Read more